Blog / Personal data
When does an agent decide under the GDPR? What the SCHUFA ruling says
Many companies think they escape Article 22 of the GDPR because a human signs at the end. The SCHUFA ruling shows the question turns not on the signature but on the real weight of what the machine produced.
By Vincent Dorange, , 2 min read
the CJEU holds that a credit score can be an automated decision
Article 22 of the GDPR gives everyone the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing, including profiling, which produces legal effects concerning them or similarly significantly affects them 1. It allows 3 exceptions: a decision necessary for a contract, authorised by Union or Member State law, or based on explicit consent.
Many organisations conclude that having a human sign the final decision is enough to fall outside the text. On 7 December 2023 the Court of Justice of the European Union showed the limits of that reasoning 2.
The SCHUFA case
A person had been refused a loan after SCHUFA, a German credit information agency, calculated an unfavourable score about them. On a reference from the Administrative Court of Wiesbaden, the Court held that the automated establishment of such a score is itself an automated individual decision under Article 22 where a third party draws strongly on it to establish, implement or terminate a contractual relationship with the person (case C-634/21).
The Court's reasoning is practical. If only the lender's final decision counted, the person could not obtain from the agency information about the logic of the calculation, even though that calculation played the determining role.
What it changes for an agent
An AI agent that prepares a decision looks a lot like that score. It screens applications, proposes refusing a refund, ranks credit files or recommends a price. In light of the ruling, if the human who approves merely follows the agent's proposal in practice, that proposal risks being treated as the decision. A rubber-stamp approval therefore offers no protection.
For each decision an agent prepares, the company needs to know whether the person approving it has a real ability to challenge it: the time, the information and the power to say no. The Agentic Commerce Framework® treats this as a design question. Human oversight is placed where it can change the outcome; the decision classification shows which decisions affect people.
Sources
Links to the official texts and original publications.
- 1Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Article 22, Official Journal of the European Union, 27 April 2016.
- 2Judgment C-634/21, OQ v Land Hessen (SCHUFA Holding), Court of Justice of the European Union, 7 December 2023.
Glossary terms used in this article
Vincent Dorange, creator of the Agentic Commerce Framework®